Categories: World

Irish hate legislation fails after intense popular backlash

In a dramatic turn of events, Sinn Féin announced Monday its opposition to the Irish Hate Speech Bill. Sinn Féin spokesman on Justice Pa Daly TD stated, “It is clear to me and to Sinn Féin that this Bill does not have support across the political spectrum.  It must be scrapped.”

During the first reading of this legislation in April 2023 every member of Sinn Féin voted in favor of the bill.

Later on Monday Minister of State Neale Richmond appearing on The Tonight Show said the bill was not passable in its current form.

Why the sudden change of stance?

In November last year an Algerian Muslim immigrant stabbed an adult and three small children near a school. In response, demonstrators took to the streets of central Dublin calling on politicians to close the border to migrants and tighten immigration policies.

Irish authorities investigated UFC champion and Irish national Conor McGregor for making “hateful” remarks on social media following the stabbing incident.

International news media and Irish officials were quick to attribute the protests to “hate” and the “far-Right.” Garda Chief Drew Harris blamed them on a “hooligan faction driven by far-right ideology.”

Then-Prime Minister Leo Varadkar responded by condemning the “hate.” “We will modernise our laws against incitement to hatred and hatred in general,” Varadkar told a news conference following the Dublin demonstrations.

The proposed legislation criminalizes possession of “hateful” material “with a view to the material being communicated to the public or a section of the public.” According to the legislation, the burden of proof lies with the accused to demonstrate that he did not intend to distribute the material.

However, the term “hate” remains undefined in the legislation.

Failure of the Irish legislation comes on the heels of similar Canadian legislation proposed last month.

Bill C-63, also known as The Online Harms Act, includes penalties for “hate” crimes extending to life imprisonment. “New standalone hate crime offence that would apply to every offence in the Criminal Code and in any other Act of Parliament, allowing penalties up to life imprisonment to denounce and deter this hateful conduct as a crime in itself,” says a technical briefing released to reporters the day the bill was tabled.

The proposed legislation also establishes a digital safety commission with broad powers to regulate social-media giants.

Canadian Civil Liberties Association Executive Director and General Counsel Noa Mendelsohn Aviv expressed concerns in an interview, citing the challenge of distinguishing between “political activism, passionate debate and offensive speech.”

To date, at least thirty countries have passed “hate” legislation. Notably, the United States has no hate speech laws due to consistent Supreme Court rulings deeming such laws unconstitutional under the First Amendment’s guarantee of freedom of speech.

Moshe Tokayer

View Comments

  • Your exemplary work demonstrates remarkable potential. With strategic enhancements, this foundation can be transformed into a pioneering contribution that advances the field and solidifies your position as an industry authority.

  • Your exemplary work demonstrates remarkable potential. With strategic enhancements, this foundation can be transformed into a pioneering contribution that advances the field and solidifies your position as an industry authority.

  • Your exemplary work demonstrates remarkable potential. With strategic enhancements, this foundation can be transformed into a pioneering contribution that advances the field and solidifies your position as an industry authority.

  • Your exemplary work demonstrates remarkable potential. With strategic enhancements, this foundation can be transformed into a pioneering contribution that advances the field and solidifies your position as an industry authority.

  • Your exemplary work demonstrates remarkable potential. With strategic enhancements, this foundation can be transformed into a pioneering contribution that advances the field and solidifies your position as an industry authority.

  • Thank you for sharing this insightful post! Your writing is clear, informative, and engaging. I appreciate how you’ve broken down complex concepts into easily digestible parts. It's evident that you have a deep understanding of the topic, and your tips are practical and actionable. I particularly liked the way you addressed [specific point from the article], as it resonated with my own experiences. This kind of content is invaluable for readers looking to expand their knowledge and apply new strategies effectively. Looking forward to reading more from you. Keep up the excellent work!

  • Thank you for sharing this insightful post! Your writing is clear, informative, and engaging. I appreciate how you’ve broken down complex concepts into easily digestible parts. It's evident that you have a deep understanding of the topic, and your tips are practical and actionable. I particularly liked the way you addressed [specific point from the article], as it resonated with my own experiences. This kind of content is invaluable for readers looking to expand their knowledge and apply new strategies effectively. Looking forward to reading more from you. Keep up the excellent work!

  • Thank you for sharing this insightful post! Your writing is clear, informative, and engaging. I appreciate how you’ve broken down complex concepts into easily digestible parts. It's evident that you have a deep understanding of the topic, and your tips are practical and actionable. I particularly liked the way you addressed [specific point from the article], as it resonated with my own experiences. This kind of content is invaluable for readers looking to expand their knowledge and apply new strategies effectively. Looking forward to reading more from you. Keep up the excellent work!

  • Thank you for sharing this insightful post! Your writing is clear, informative, and engaging. I appreciate how you’ve broken down complex concepts into easily digestible parts. It's evident that you have a deep understanding of the topic, and your tips are practical and actionable. I particularly liked the way you addressed [specific point from the article], as it resonated with my own experiences. This kind of content is invaluable for readers looking to expand their knowledge and apply new strategies effectively. Looking forward to reading more from you. Keep up the excellent work!

  • Thank you for sharing this insightful post! Your writing is clear, informative, and engaging. I appreciate how you’ve broken down complex concepts into easily digestible parts. It's evident that you have a deep understanding of the topic, and your tips are practical and actionable. I particularly liked the way you addressed [specific point from the article], as it resonated with my own experiences. This kind of content is invaluable for readers looking to expand their knowledge and apply new strategies effectively. Looking forward to reading more from you. Keep up the excellent work!

Recent Posts

Israelis initiate movement promoting Jewish settlement in southern Lebanon

As Israel's north absorbs fatal rocket attacks by the Hezbollah Islamic organization, a movement of…

8 months ago

Bridges, airplanes, and diversity exterminating competence: Analysis

The ship that collided this week with Baltimore's Key Bridge, the MV Dali container vessel,…

8 months ago

Pressure mounts on British health secretary to come clean on vaccine fallout

A bipartisan group of British lawmakers is pressuring Health Secretary Victoria Atkins to prove government…

8 months ago

Comedian slams woke assault on comedy

TV host and comedian Howie Mandel last week joined a chorus of other comedy artists…

8 months ago

TikTok censors anti-birth control content at media’s request

TikTok is removing videos that criticize hormonal birth control for being “misinformation” at the request…

8 months ago

Former National Security Advisor calls Key Bridge collision ‘Black Swan event’

Former National Security Advisor General Mike Flynn called today's destruction of Baltimore's Key Bridge a…

8 months ago